About us

A neighborhood brokerage for drivers who have been told no

For many years, All Suffolk Brokerage has helped Long Island drivers who were declined, canceled, or priced out of the market get insured, then helped them back to better rates.

A bright broker’s office with a walnut desk and two navy client chairs

Our story

Built around the people other agencies turn away.

Many insurance offices are set up to sell one company’s policy to drivers with clean records. The people who need help most, like a teenager with a brand-new license, a student commuting to Selden, a driver with two tickets, or someone whose policy was canceled after a missed payment, often get a quick “we can’t write that.”

All Suffolk Brokerage was built for those calls. We are an independent brokerage on Route 109 in West Babylon, and assigned-risk auto insurance through the New York Automobile Insurance Plan is the center of our work. Over the years we have helped Suffolk County drivers get coverage when they thought they couldn’t, and saved many of them money by checking every option available before settling on one.

We also place homeowners, business, BOP, general liability, workers compensation, and flood coverage, so families and small business owners can keep everything with an office that already knows them.

Our job is to find the way to “yes,” then make sure you understand what you’re paying for.

How we work

What you can expect from us.

No judgment

Tickets, accidents, a lapse, a cancellation. We have seen it before. We just need the facts so we can find a policy that works.

Many carriers, not one

As brokers, we work on your behalf and compare the carriers and programs available to us, instead of steering you to a single insurer.

Plain English

We explain what each coverage does, what New York requires, and where you can save, without the jargon.

We stay with you

ID cards, DMV letters, adding a driver, a new car, a claim question, a renewal review. You call the same office.

Where we work

Long Island first, with clients across New York.

Our office is in West Babylon, and most of our clients live and work in Suffolk and Nassau, including students at Stony Brook University, Suffolk County Community College, and Farmingdale State College. If you are elsewhere in New York State, we can help you by phone, text, and email.

Get in touch

Call, text, or email. We take it from there.

Everything from the first quote to your ID cards is handled by phone, text, and email, so you never have to make a trip. Send us what you have and we will tell you exactly what else we need.

Office hours

Messages and quote requests are welcome any time.

Office hours
Monday9 AM – 6 PM
Tuesday9 AM – 6 PM
Wednesday9 AM – 6 PM
Thursday9 AM – 6 PM
Friday9 AM – 6 PM
Saturday9 AM – 2 PM
SundayClosed

Turned down somewhere else? Call us before you give up.

Tell us what happened. We’ll go over your options, including the New York assigned-risk plan, and tell you honestly what it will take to get you insured.

Start my quote (631) 906-7824

Request a quote online any time. We reply by phone, text, or email.